There’s a question that comes up in every single training program interview, and most candidates answer it badly.
The question is, in some form: “Why this specialty? Why surgery? Why medicine? Why anaesthetics? Why GP?”
I’ve sat on a lot of panels. I’ve watched a lot of clever, well-prepared candidates lose marks here because they reach for the same three answers:
- “I love the lifestyle.”
- “I want to help people.”
- “I find it intellectually challenging.”
Each is technically true. Each is meaningless. Every applicant says them. None of them tell the panel anything about you.
So the rubric — and there usually is a rubric — gives them low marks.
What panels are actually scoring
Three things, in this order:
- Have you demonstrated understanding of what the work is actually like — including its hard parts?
- Is your stated motivation consistent with the evidence in your CV — your placements, your audits, your study choices?
- Do you have a specific, plausible plan for the next two to five years that matches the program?
Notice what’s not on that list — passion, love, joy. Passion matters, and we’ll come back to it. But first: panels are looking for evidence of fit, not enthusiasm.
The VERG™ framework
The four-letter scaffold I use with the doctors I coach: VERG™ — Value, Entrustment, Readiness, Gratitude.
Build your answer in that order and you’ll cover every scoring criterion above — and you’ll close on a note panels remember. Value tells the panel what you’d add. Entrustment proves you’ve already been doing it.
V — Value
The value you bring to this role and program — your contribution, named in concrete terms.
Not “I want to be here.” Rather: “here’s what I add.”
“I bring three years of focused theatre time including 200-plus documented assists in upper GI, two completed audits that changed protocol on the ward I worked, and two years of running our JMO orientation programme. That means I can step into a senior reg role with a built-in framework for teaching the next cohort — and I think that’s the value I’d add to this unit.”
Specific capabilities. Concrete projects. A perspective the unit doesn’t currently have. The strongest answers name what they’d unlock for the program — not just what the candidate finds interesting.
E — Entrustment
What more senior people have trusted you to do — the most significant and risky things they’ve handed you.
This is where you describe a specific moment when a consultant or senior reg gave you real responsibility. What was at stake. Your independent judgement. The outcome. Ideally the senior person’s own endorsement afterwards.
“Last year my consultant trusted me to manage an unstable patient overnight while she was in theatre — a deteriorating GI bleed needing escalation to interventional radiology at 3am. I made the call to escalate independently. The patient went to IR and did well. The next morning she debriefed me and said it was the right judgement. That kind of trust is what tells me I’m ready for the next stage.”
This is much stronger than a CV recitation. A list of placements tells the panel what you’ve done; a moment of demonstrated trust tells them what you’ve already earned. Entrustment is what senior clinicians look for in registrars — show them you’ve been operating at that level already.
R — Readiness
How ready you are for the demands of this specialty — including the hard parts.
This is the bit most candidates skip.
“I know the training pathway is long and that the consultant lifestyle in regional Australia involves a lot of on-call, especially in the first ten years out. I’ve spoken to four current trainees about that, including two who left and came back. I am prepared for this.”
That sentence does enormous work. It says you’re not naïve, you’ve done your research, and you’re choosing this with eyes open. Readiness isn’t just “I want to do it” — it’s “I know what it costs and I’ve still chosen it.”
G — Gratitude
The close. Where you bring it back to why this matters — but framed through gratitude rather than self-promotion.
Gratitude works because it shifts the tone from “look at me” to “look at what I’ve been given the chance to be part of.” It’s professional, warm, and memorable.
“I think about that 2am theatre case more than I should admit. I’m grateful to the team at Westmead who let me be in the room, and to the patients who’ve trusted me along the way. That’s why I’m here today.”
This is where passion belongs. Anchored, humble, specific.
A few traps
- Don’t lie. If the evidence trail isn’t there, don’t invent it — the follow-up question will catch you out.
- Don’t pick a specialty for the prestige and try to dress it up. Every panellist can smell that within thirty seconds.
- Don’t apologise for an unconventional path. Career changers and IMGs often hedge here. Don’t. Tell the story directly.
A practice prompt
Record yourself on your phone, answering “why this specialty?” in 90 seconds using the VERG™ order.
Watch it back. If you used “passionate,” “love,” or “lifestyle” without explicit evidence, rewrite. If your answer would work for any specialty, it’s not a real answer.
Get the rubric and worked examples
The full VERG™t scoring rubric plus worked examples for surgical, physician, GP and emergency answers is available as a one-page resource for coaching clients. Book a Clarity Call and we’ll go through your draft answer together — and you’ll leave with the rubric and worked examples.
Related Posts
-
Coaching for Doctors. What Are the Key Benefits?
There are many key benefits or advantages to coaching for doctors, including better communication, time management, self-awareness, and problem-solving skills.
-
How To Write A Medical CV. The Ultimate Guide.
Updated for 2025. Tips From a Medical HR Expert On How to Write a Medical CV or Resume. Includes What To Put On the All-important 1st Page. Examples & Illustrations.
-
The Benefits Of A CV Check – Why You Should Get Your CV Reviewed. Medical CV Australia.
The Benefit of a CV Check or Resume Review As we enter the new academic year for medicine in Australia and New Zealand many doctors are thinking about whether they might be applying for a new position in 2020. Yes. It’s that competitive in some situations. That even before you have commenced your current job…
